top of page
  • Writer's pictureMichelle

Tea and Confession: a Short Story

Happy New Year! 2022 was a BEAST of a year, but we made it through. I'm not even going to try to imagine what 2023 will bring (besides my novella, Briar, which is available TOMORROW!), so let's just read a nice story, shall we? This is another story you might recognize from the old Hagstone Publishing Website. I have just a few more stories left to bring over to this site, and then, who knows? Maybe I'll have some new stories to share with you. I hope you enjoy this one.

A painting of two people beside a small table with a white pitcher and cups of tea.  Painting by Claudia Olivos. Used with permission.

2 years ago you sat at my table while I made you tea. You didn’t see, but I slipped a love potion in your cup. Imagine my surprise when it worked.

Tonight there’s a small velvet box in your pocket. It’s supposed to be a surprise, but your room mate let the secret slip when I called for you yesterday, and now I guess I should tell you the truth.

You walk in with flowers. You bring flowers every Friday, always something sweet smelling. Freesia, Roses, sweet little Stephanotis that fades to brown by morning. Tonight the heady scent of Casablanca Lilies envelopes me when I open the door, and I find a vase while you slip off your heavy wool coat and step out of your muddy shoes.

“It’s very January out there,” you tell me, “and traffic was terrible.”

I love you more every day. I love your laugh and the way you smell and the way you sing Bruce Springsteen tunes off key in the shower. I love the way you examine the innards of your sandwich before you eat it and the way you check the locks three times before you leave for work. And today I have to tell you the truth, and I have to tell you before that box comes out of your pocket. Because I want to marry you, and I know if I don’t tell you now I’ll never be able to tell you after you put a ring on my finger.

So you sit down and I make you a cup of tea, the same kind I made for you that night, the tea you said was the best cup of tea you ever drank right before you pinned me against the wall in the hallway and kissed me.

You toy with your cup, looking guilty. I stare at my hands, feeling guilty. Finally we both blurt at the same moment: “I have something I have to tell you.”

We laugh, but my heart is pounding.

“You first,” you say, and for the first time I wish you weren’t so considerate.

I take a deep breath.

“Okay,” I say. “I know you think you love me. But you don’t.”

“But I do,” you say.

I wave at your steaming mug.

“It’s not real. That night--the first time you kissed me--I put a love potion in your tea.”

You stare at me for a few minutes, and I expect you to be angry, but you laugh. You get up and hug me.

“Maybe I should have made my confession first,” you say, and my fear returns, stronger than before. Now that my secret is out and you haven’t left me yet, I wonder what you could possibly have to reveal.

“Go ahead,” I say.

“I hate tea. All tea. Every kind of tea I’ve ever had.”

“But you said . . .”

You laugh again, apologetically.

“I lied to you because I didn't want to hurt your feelings. I never drank that tea. I fed it to your ficus when you excused yourself to answer the phone.”

Now I remember walking away from the table that night, coming back to find your cup empty. I offered more, and you said no, you were watching your caffeine.

And the ficus tree grew more lush and enormous over that severe winter, in spite of frequent power failures and even more frequent watering failures. Until you and I went away together for a week, to Vermont to visit your parents, and when I came back the tree was dead, though I’d hired someone to water and all the other plants were thriving. They replaced my ficus; who would believe my tree died of a broken heart?

And you loved me for two years while I swam in guilt. I blink at you, and you are smiling but you also look a little nervous, like I might be mad at you.

“So how many cups of tea have you wasted these past two years?” I ask, torn between relief and embarrassment.

You shake your head and kiss me.

“I say we’re even,” you say, and I laugh.

“Right,” I answer. “Even.”

And I hold my breath as you reach for the box in your pocket.

story ©Michelle Simkins, 2011

artwork ©Claudia Olivos, 2011. Used with permission. Find more of Claudia's visionary work at Olivos Art Studio or at her Etsy store, and don't forget to follow her on Instagram.

If this post inspired or informed you, or just made you happy, feel free to buy me a cup of ko-fi. Your support helps with the cost of web hosting and other expenses, allowing me to spend more time creating posts for you.

26 views0 comments


Image by Annie Spratt

Michelle Simkins

polytheist . writer . maker . witch

bottom of page